David Archuleta Is a Charmer!

Brian Mansfield of Idol Chatter is running a poll based on the list of “American Idol” charmers listed last week by Shirley Halperin of the L.A. Times. (See “That Charming David Archuleta!” post from April 24 if you need to refresh your memory on David’s description.)

Here’s what the introduction to the poll says:

In honor of Tim Urban, whom she found to be quite gentlemanly and eternally optimistic, Shirley Halperin of the Los Angeles Times has created a list of Idol’s biggest charmers.

Here’s how Shirley ranks them:

1.David Cook
2.Adam Lambert
3.Casey James
4.Kellie Pickler
5.David Archuleta

What do you think? Was she right? Did Shirley leave anybody off? Which Idols have charmed you most, in person or on television? Share your stories.

Wait no more! Cast your vote for the charming David Archuleta here!